LGBT Community Forum - Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgendered & Drag Network Home 
Home Search search Menu menu Not logged in - Login | Register


Supreme Court Rules for Protestors at Gay Soldier's Funeral - video
 Moderated by: Admin
Articles New Topic Reply Printer Friendly
 Rating:  Rating
AuthorPost
 Posted: 2011-03-03 05:52 am
  PMQuoteReply
1st Post
Admin



Joined: 2009-03-18
Location:  
Posts: 349
Status: 
Offline


 

what do you think about this?  is hate speach included with free speach?

Back To Top


 Posted: 2012-03-12 02:31 pm
  PMQuoteReply
2nd Post
alderinordell

 

Joined: 2012-03-12
Location:  
Posts: 3
Status: 
Offline
I think i never hate this speech. I really appreciate that it is a biggest crime to break feeling of others and stop them to live as they wants.

Back To Top


 Posted: 2012-03-13 12:43 am
  PMQuoteReply
3rd Post
marshmallow

 

Joined: 2011-05-25
Location:  
Posts: 217
Status: 
Offline
As much as I do not want to say this, I feel as if all speech has to be allowed BY LAW.  So, someone talking hate speech can't be arrested.  However, we as individuals and groups can rise up and fight against their hate speech, whether by demonstration or through some economical means.

Back To Top


 Posted: 2012-03-13 06:12 am
  PMQuoteReply
4th Post
Jerry

 

Joined: 2011-12-01
Location:  
Posts: 8
Status: 
Offline
In short, no, I don't believe "speech" is absolutely free. Rather, I feel the expression of ideas and opinions is totally free, and other types of speech are free to the extent that they do not cause harm. Hate speech and speech that incites violent are typical examples of when it isn't completely "free."

For example, I can say that "I don't like gay people" and I'm perfectly within my rights to state that opinion, but as soon as I say something like "I think everyone should attack gay people "I'm no longer simply expressing an opinion, I'm inciting violence.

(Disclaimer: Obviously, those statements don't reflect my true opinions, just using them as examples of statements people might make)

Now let's look at the specific example of that video. While it may be acceptable under many circumstances for a group to express their opinions about homosexuality, in this case it was clearly harassment. In my country, those "protestors" would have been arrested, undoubtedly. Here, anything like that would be considered outright hate speech, which is illegal. Also, homosexuality is protected under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, so any person who questions someone's right to equality is effectively committing a crime.

Last edited on 2012-03-13 06:22 am by Jerry

Back To Top


 Posted: 2012-03-13 06:46 am
  PMQuoteReply
5th Post
marshmallow

 

Joined: 2011-05-25
Location:  
Posts: 217
Status: 
Offline
You make a very interesting point Jerry.  I would agree that if there is a separate law which makes Hate Speech illegal that would be a very good thing.  I luv Canada and that is one of the reasons.  Has there been a lot of litigation with people arguing the subtleties of what is and isn't hate speech? 

Last edited on 2012-03-22 06:55 am by marshmallow

Back To Top


 Posted: 2012-03-13 02:06 pm
  PMQuoteReply
6th Post
modernbard

 

Joined: 2011-01-23
Location:  
Posts: 1
Status: 
Offline
I'm going to play devil's advocate here and say, as much as I hate and loath what people, like those of the west boro church, are doing, they have a constitutional right to do so.  A right protected by LAW to say exactly what they think and feel.  A law written by our founding fathers who felt we should have the right to speak against the injustice and inequities around us.

Do I believe this is exactly what they intended when they wrote the constitution?  Not even close.  Does this mean I condone what the members of the west boro church are doing to family members of the deceased?  Absolutely not!  I am in the camp of "just because it can be said, doesn't mean it SHOULD be said.  And because I feel this way and I have the right to protest back, you will find me in the ranks of the bikers, revving their engines to block out the noise of the protesters.

And remember, hate groups such as west boro and the KKK have a right to speak; no one said we had to listen!

Back To Top


 Posted: 2012-03-17 01:25 am
  PMQuoteReply
7th Post
firespot
Hero Of Destiny!


Joined: 2010-02-04
Location:  
Posts: 12
Status: 
Offline
In my opinion, there is a difference between expressing an opinion and being a jerk.

I think it's fine if someone says they don't like gay people, but when they say something like "I hate them, they should die and they're going to hell" I find that downright rude and nasty!

I think freedom of speech is fine, but being mean about it isn't.

I know this is a crazy idea, but too bad there isn't a group just like westboro baptist church, that was anti WBC.
That would probably be a really interesting thing to see.



____________________
The Bubbling cauldron~ A forum for LGBT too!
http://www.thebubblingcauldron.net/lgbt/index.php
Back To Top


 Posted: 2012-03-20 04:05 am
  PMQuoteReply
8th Post
72jay



Joined: 2011-10-15
Location: Outside City Limits, Colorado USA
Posts: 14
Status: 
Offline
I believe in the right to free speech, and see an issue if you start banning bits & pieces of it...that starts a bad precedent of weeding away at a fundamental right. Plus who determines what is banned?

While I consider protesting outside a funeral is a level way below distasteful and disrespectful, at the same time as much as I hate the idea I would say its protected by free speech...now if they actually get inside and disrupt a funeral, then that I see as both harassment and invasion of privacy. In which case they should be arrested.

Back To Top


 Posted: 2012-03-20 05:06 am
  PMQuoteReply
9th Post
Admin



Joined: 2009-03-18
Location:  
Posts: 349
Status: 
Offline
This is such a tough one.  And the subject has been coming up alot.  I heard gloria Feldt (Fmr President of Planned Parenthood) addressing freedom of speech vs. hate speech when she was discussing Rush's hateful comments about the woman who testified regarding contraceptives.  She seems to feel there is a fine line between free speech and hate speech and is leading a movement to sue Rush and bring him down (in the court of law)  based on the fact that he crossed the line of free speech into hate speech - and that there is a difference.

On the opposite side, there is the ACLU who says that defending freedom of speech is easy when the message is not that difficult to hear, however, the defense of freedom of speech is most critical when the message is terrible and difficult to hear.

I sorta feel once we start trying to draw a line between hate speech and free speech then free speech comes under take and vulnerable to interpretation.  At that point it can change in the wind depending on who is the judge or how the law is interpreted. 

I think the most powerful way to fight against the Westboro Church is for activists to show up in such great numbers - and in a peaceful way - so as to block out the hate message and to offer comfort to the grieving families.  This concept is, I think, what Firespot was talking about in his post.  Only less negative - not shouting hate at the church - causing more stress - but singing comforting hymns to the family, holding candles and drowning out the hate with the positive.

 

 

Last edited on 2012-03-20 05:08 am by Admin

Back To Top


 Posted: 2012-03-21 11:56 pm
  PMQuoteReply
10th Post
Reptillian

 

Joined: 2011-03-15
Location:  
Posts: 3
Status: 
Offline
I got to say this though, any acceptance on the attempt to reduce any rights of any individuals from any group can go against itself. Words are just stick and stones which does absolutely nothing if you actually learn that (I been through verbal assaults and I shrug it off easily unlike physical bullying which I tend to get angry at.). Words can be used like a sword for those who's vulnerable and words can be used as a defense system. But words will not affect those who seem to be not caring enough to be affected by it.

Back To Top


 Posted: 2012-06-15 05:38 pm
  PMQuoteReply
11th Post
cedrick08

 

Joined: 2012-06-15
Location:  
Posts: 1
Status: 
Offline
This is a very good point.But i believe that every one has the right to speech.



____________________
For more about cleaning gold coast visit the website and good used cars. Then como aparecer en google enjoy.
Back To Top


 Posted: 2017-11-21 10:03 am
  PMQuoteReply
12th Post
lzm00
Guest
 

Joined: 
Location:  
Posts: 
Status: 
Offline
louis vuitton bags
authentic shoes
pandora rings
pandora rings
puma sale
Premier Jewelry. - Official
kanye west shoes sale
rayban wayfarer
tiffany
kate spade handbags on sale
birkenstock outlet
burberry bags
Nike Air Jordan Femme
ralph lauren polo
gold michele watch
The Retail Compliance Association

jimmy choo outlet sale
coach carter
michael kors outlet online store
rayban sunglasses
Mizuno Shoes
Coach Sunglasses Outlet
Wholesale womens autumn winter clothing
michael kors bags outlet
school bags online sale store
KD 8 shoes
yeezy boost
kate spade uk sale
Burberry Shirt - Official
ray ban sunglasses
michael kors
Nike Air Max Lebron 10
coach outlet
burberry outlet sale online
louis vuitton outlet store
payless shoes online store
michael kors purses
Nike Roshe Run Femme
coach outlet online sale
kate spade outlet bags on Sale
michael kors australia sale
michael kors outlet online store
coach australia online shop
birkenstock australia
zales jewelry outlet
tiffany
louis vuitton outle sale
louis vuitton sale
michael kors black friday sale
China Wholesale
school bags online store
kate spade outlet
coach outlet store
prada outlet online
nfl jerseys
adidas yeezy boost 350
michael kors outlet online
Ray Ban Outlet store
birkenstock sandals outlet sale
kate spade bags
ray ban erika sunglasses
80's,eighties fashion
coach usa
ray ban polarized
Nike Air Presto
coach bags
under armour outlet online
pandora charms uk
michael kors online
new yeezy shoes
Nike Air Max Lunar 90 Damen
michael kors factory outlet
black friday michael kors store
ray ban glasses frames
Prada Shoes - Official
Prada Bags
burberry outlet on sale
coach
polo outlet online
nike air
pandora rings uk
kate spade on sale
ray ban outlet store
Family Name Research
kate spade online
kate spade bags
Birkin Bag Hermes
Pembesar Penis
Air Jordan 4 Femme
sac louis vuitton
kate spade bags outlet
Nike Air Jordan Femmes
Coach Handbags
michael kors outlet online sale
Nike Air Max
cheap ray ban
prada factory outlet
ups tracking number
michael kors bags on sale
abercrombie canada
Nike Air Max TN
Black Friday Ads
payless shoes online
rayban aviator
ray ban wayfarer
ray ban prescription sunglasses
Jewelry Armoire - Official
michael kors outlet
mlb shop
Coach Factory Outlet
louis vuitton online
chrome hearts jewelry
puma shoes online store
black friday deals
soccer shop
tạp chí ẩm thực
michael kors outlet sale
chrome hearts
chrome store
Jared Jewelry - Official
michael kors uk online
payless shoes outlet sale
diesel watches for men
Nike Free,Nike Shox
Air Jordan
Green Cleaned
michael kors outlet online sale
Prada Outlet
Engagement Rings - Official
rayban wayfarer
michael kors shop australia store
evbid
trx workout plan
kay jewelers
Nike Air Jordan Femme
kate spade
under armour
Air Max 87 Homme
skechers shoes sale
michael kors bags
michael kors
burberry bags sale
rolex watches for men
official prada site
pandora australia sale
celine outlet
birkenstock sandals online
jimmy choo australia online store
pandora rings sale
birkenstock outlet online
burberry outlet store
baseball jerseys
Louis Vuitton USA
michael kors australia online
Nike Air Max Flywire
louis vuitton uk
Dreamland Jewelry - Official
eznara
payless
puma outlet
Nike Air Max 95 Homme
ray ban sale online
puma online store
Jordan Fusion Homme
mcm outlet
prada online
hermes belt for sale
Online Oyun
Brighton Jewelry - Official
fake sunglasses sale
kate spade
rayban prescription glasses
kate spade
mk,australia
breitling watches for sale
Air Jordan Fusion
michael kors outlet
Promise Rings - Official
omega watches for sale
pandora rings
michael kors bags
Ray Ban
burberry book bags
Burberry Australia
birkenstock sale
Nike Free Run
louis vuitton
ray ban outlet online
kate spade outlet sale store
michael kors australia for sale
Mizuno Shop Japan
coach outlet
adidas yeezy boost
michael kors outlet
adidas online
rolex watches for men
ray ban sunglasses sale
chaussures pas cher en ligne
timberland boots sale
adidas yeezy boost 350
hermes outlet sale online
vêtements de mode
clb sports shoes
jimmy choo outlet sale store
ray-ban eyeglasses
pandora bracelet uk
Lunette Oakley Ducati Scalpel en soldes
oakley australia
puma outlet sale
moncler jacket
burberry sale
ray ban online
michael kors outlet online store
birkenstock canada sale
louis vuitton outlet online sale
black friday sales online
Premier Jewelry - Official
louis vuitton bags
Nike Schuhe Mädchen
kate spade outlet sale
coach outlet
pandora bracelet
search
Nike Schuhe Jungen
pandora charms sale
jimmy choo shoes on sale
kate spade outlet online sale
chrome hearts
louis vuitton bags
uggs outlet
michael kors bags outlet
michael kors
puma shoes online sale
under armour on sale
kate spade outlet canada
pandora rings uk
kate spade outlet online sale
jimmy choo shoes sale
Air Max 95 Femme
pandora rings
coach factory outlet online store
Prada Sunglasses - Official
swatch store
Prada Shoes - Official
Nike Schuhe
timberland boots on sale
Nike Air Max 90
hermes outlet store
Nike Air Max TN
pandora jewelry charms
Air MAX SKYLINE
puma sneakers online store
fulam shoes sale
Air Max TN Homme
Air Max 90 Enfant
michael kors australia
Michael Kors Canada
Dreamland Jewelry - Official
casio watches for women
Nike Air Max 2017
shoes sale
kate spade outlet
Coach Purses Outlet
payless shoes store
pandora rings
oakley australia store
Jewelry Armoire - Official
pandora bracelet
kate spade shopping bags
michael kors australia online sale
pandora charms outlet
asics gel kayano
ray ban sunglasses
birkenstock sandals sale
kate spade outlet online store
michael kors factory outlet sale
Diamond Rings - Official
pandora necklace sale
Nike Air Max 95
kate spade outlet sale
boulder shoes sale
Longchamp Sale
burberry bags outlet on sale
ermes bag for sale
ugg slippers sale
Nike Air Jordan Femme
Wedding Rings- Official
kate spade purses outlet sale
burberry coupon
ray ban outlet online
Jordan Aero Mania Homme
michael kors bags online
michael kors shoes outlet
prada outlet
chanel bag
nike huarache shoes
coachs outlet sale
coach outlet
puma sale
michael kors factory outlet
AIR MAX LTD 2
Salomon Shoes
coach outlet
Coach Outlet
under armour shoes online
Air Max Homme
Coach Outlet Coupon
kate spade sale
Wholesale Outlet Sale
Air Jordan Femme
ray ban australia
nike chaussure
oakley sunglasses
ray ban clubmaster sunglasses
buy under armour stock
Nike Air Max Light
Jared Jewelry - Official
Nike Air Max TN Femme
pandora charms
ugg

coach handbags
kate spade online sale
Michael Kors Handbags Outlet Sale
louis vuitton sale
Nike Jordan Shoes
pandora rings
Add Your Link Free
kate spade official
coach outlet store
Nike Air Max LTD
Nike Blazer
ray ban shop sale
kate spade outlet online store
pandora bracelet
prada sale
coach factory outlet
wordpress
oakley sunglasses
coach sale online
michael kors outlet sale
mens sunglasses
nike outlet sale
kate spade
ugg boots outlet
trazodone100mg
pandora charm necklace
hermes belt men
Air Jordan
coach handbags
michael kors outlet
the beat
puma sneakers sale
jimmy choo australia on sale
canada goose outlet online store
hermes bag birkin
Air Max Femme
jimmy choo heels on sale
rayban glasses
gucci women watches
kate spade bags store
Louis Vuitton outlet
hermes uk
cartier watches for men
pandora outlet
michael kors outlet
michael kors bags
oakley outlet online store
Nike Air Jordan
coach factory outlet sale
timberland boots
cool math games
black friday 2016
mode damenschuhe
oakley sunglasses for sale
oakley outlet sale
north face outlet sale
snow boots
black friday online
Air Max BW Femme
import sunglasses
school bags store
seiko automatic watches
Cheap Ray Ban
Air Max 90
Air Max 90 Femme
coach handbags
pandora bracelet
Air Jordan
longchamp outlet online
christian louboutin shoes
louis vuitton outlet sale
pandora charms sale
nike running
Nike Air Max LTD
Nike Air Max 90 pas cher france
michael kors handbags sale
spendless shoes sale
jimmy choo shoes outlet
ugg
pandora rings
ray ban sunglasses
coach shoes
jimmy choo outlet online sale
michael kors outlet online sale
prada handbags
Markenschuhe
michael kors uk sale
yeezy shoes kids
chrome store
kate spade new york
Nike Free Homme
kate spade outlet sale
kate spade outlet online store
michael kors australia on sale
ray ban sunglasses
prada outlet online sale
michael kors australia
sunglasses online
salomon boots
pandora earrings on sale
pandora rings
adidas yeezy boost 350
michael kors outlet sale
kate spade wallet
small business
timberland shoes online sale
balenciaga outlet online store
classic
puma suede online
michael kors outlet sale store
Air Jordan Flight
ray ban sunglasses
talons
Nike Air Max 95
Nike Air Griffey Max Homme
burberry outlet sale
Brighton Jewelry - Official
prada outlet online
moncler outlet
michael kors bags
Nike DUNKSB
Nike Air Max 90
moncler clothing
birkenstock gizeh sale
ray ban justin sunglasses
michael kors outlet online
coach factory outlet online store
pandora australia online store
Air Max 180
prada bags
moncler jacket
kate spade collection 2017
under armour outlet store
chaussures asics homme
Nike Air Jordan Homme
Michael Kors
cheap ray ban
kate spade online store
Louis Vuitton Outlet Online
louis vuitton bags online sale
best website directory
kate spade outlet online store
Nike Air Max BW
pandora online outlet
coach outlet online
burberry sale store
pandora jewelry
CHanel Factory Outlet
goose outlet sale
Doxycycline
pandora charms sale
payless shoes store
michael kors australia
Kaufen Nike Air Max 1
Oakley Sunglasses
michael kors outlet online store
kate spade australia
payless coupons
jimmy choo shoes sale
handbags online
outlet sale online
pandora charms uk sale
Nike Blazer
Michael Kors Outlet
oakley sunglasses
Nike Air Max 90 Damen
ray ban australia store
ray ban sunglasses outlet sale
nba shop
timberland sale
2015 Nike Dunk
ray ban outlet on sale
Nike Schuhe
ray-ban outlet
nike jordan
Pharmacy Discount Network
hot burberry bags
moncler us
Nike Air Max BW
louis vuitton factory outlet
kate spade outlet online
black friday ads
Air Jordan 1
coach outlet
pandora bracelet
mk outlet online store
michael kors outlet online store
Nike Air Max 90
Abercrombie Nederland
prada outlet online
michael kors uk
Lisinopril 2.5 Mg Cost
Mens Sunglasses
jimmy choo uk sale
louis vuitton shop
louis vuitton online
birkenstock outlet store
louis vuitton handbags
puma outlet online
mk outlet online
sunglasses hut
Nike Air Max TN
Prada bags
brand sunglasses
Nike Blazer Homme
Nike Air Max LTD
ugg outlet sale
chanel outlet online
lzm11.21

Back To Top


Current time is 09:52 am

Top



UltraBB 1.17 Copyright © 2007-2008 Data 1 Systems